Finding control in a volatile world

Finding control in a volatile world

Finding control in a volatile world

From volatility to control

What energy market volatility can teach us about institutional resilience.

Adam Clarke, Managing Director, The Energy Consortium

 

Volatility may have become a permanent feature of the energy landscape, but unmanaged exposure does not have to be

That was one of my clearest takeaways from our recent TEC Conference and from the panel discussion I joined with senior leaders from the Higher Education and energy sectors.

We cannot reliably predict the next geopolitical shock, policy change or interruption to global energy markets. What struck me during the discussion, however, was that perhaps we spend too much time trying to anticipate events we cannot control, and not enough focusing on the areas where institutions genuinely can make a difference.

For Finance, Procurement and institutional leaders, I think that requires a change in emphasis. Rather than trying to forecast every turn in an increasingly unpredictable market, we should be asking a different question: where can we create greater control?

For me, the answer lies in strengthening control over the risks, costs and decisions that sit within our influence.

 

Control starts with alignment

I have long believed that one of the challenges with energy is that responsibility rarely sits in one place.

Procurement, Finance, Estates and Sustainability each hold part of the answer, but no single team necessarily sees the complete picture. That matters because energy decisions increasingly cut across all four.

This is where I see real value in an effective Energy Working Group. Not as another layer of meetings or bureaucracy, but as a practical forum that brings together consumption data, budget exposure, procurement strategy, estate investment and carbon commitments.

Done well, this creates the conditions for much better decisions. Finance can understand future exposure; Procurement can align contracts and frameworks with institutional priorities; Estates can identify operational opportunities; and Sustainability teams can connect carbon plans with deliverable investment.

Alongside this, prudent commodity hedging remains essential. TEC’s approach continues to provide members with greater budget certainty and protection from extreme short- to medium-term market movements. Hedging cannot remove every risk, nor should we pretend that it can. But it can help prevent volatility in the market becoming uncontrolled volatility in institutional budgets.

 

Better data creates better choices

Institutions cannot manage what they cannot see.

One of the simplest messages from the conference was also one of the most important: we cannot manage what we cannot see.

For me, this means going back to basics. How much energy are we consuming? When are we consuming it? And, crucially, where?

Once we have that visibility, the conversation becomes much more interesting. Persistent baseload becomes easier to identify. Equipment operating unnecessarily becomes visible. Buildings running outside required hours can be challenged.

And where consumption cannot be eliminated, we can start asking whether it can be moved.

Shifting flexible consumption away from peak periods can reduce exposure to higher wholesale prices and increasingly significant non-commodity charges. This turns energy management from something largely reactive into something much more deliberate.

I therefore see enhanced metering and BEMS recommissioning not simply as technical estate projects, but as financial control measures. Their real value is in turning data into operational action and measurable savings.

For senior leaders, the important question is no longer whether their institution possesses energy data. Almost certainly it does. The question is whether that data is sufficiently accurate, accessible and timely to support good operational and investment decisions.

 

Combine immediate action with strategic investment

Another point I took from the discussion was that greater control does not always require significant capital investment.

There are relatively straightforward interventions that can make an immediate difference: moving EV charging overnight, introducing clear heating and cooling policies, improving operating schedules and strengthening building controls.

These actions matter. But I think the bigger opportunity comes when institutions connect today’s operational improvements with tomorrow’s investment decisions.

Behind-the-meter technologies such as solar PV, battery storage, heat pumps and other on-site assets are changing the relationship between institutions and the electricity system. They offer the potential not only to lower cost and carbon, but also to avoid peak demand, create greater operational flexibility and support grid stability.

This is where I think the way we assess investment also needs to evolve.

The strongest business cases will look at these benefits together rather than in isolation. Energy savings matter, but so do avoided network costs, carbon reduction, resilience and flexibility.

For Finance and Procurement leaders, therefore, perhaps the question should no longer simply be “What is the payback period?”

It should also be: “What combination of financial, operational and strategic value does this investment create, and what is the cost of delaying it?”

 

A resilient institution relies on a resilient estate

For me, one of the most thought-provoking parts of the conference was the discussion about the future shape of institutional estates.

Resilience is not only about making existing assets more efficient. In some cases, it may require a more fundamental conversation about the size, quality and purpose of the estate itself.

We heard the University of Cambridge describe its vision for a higher-quality estate, including shared spaces that encourage collaboration and strengthen community. The University of Nottingham outlined its plans to better align its estate with institutional priorities, including a significant strategic reduction of approximately 20% in its non-residential estate footprint.

These examples highlighted an important challenge facing most members.

If the way we teach, work and use our campuses is changing, how should our estates change with it?

Energy strategy and estate strategy cannot sensibly be considered separately. Continuing to invest in inefficient or underused buildings may preserve capacity, but it does not necessarily create value. Rightsizing the estate can potentially release resources, reduce exposure to future energy costs and create better environments for students and staff.

The disappearance of readily available low-cost capital clearly makes these decisions harder. But arguably it makes making the right decisions even more important.

Private investment and alternative commercial models may provide routes to accelerate energy and decarbonisation projects. The important thing, in my view, is that institutions remain clear about risk allocation, long-term value and where strategic control ultimately sits.

 

Collaboration turns individual action into collective resilience

One thing I was reminded of throughout the conference is just how willing our members are to share their experience with one another.

TEC’s energy frameworks already demonstrate what can be achieved through purchasing power at scale, giving members greater resilience and market protection. TEC are exploring how taking group buying may be expanded beyond energy procurement. I believe the opportunity for collective advantage goes much further than commodity procurement.

If institutions share data, project experience and commercial learning more effectively, we can avoid repeatedly solving the same problems in isolation. We can learn from approaches that worked, understand those that didn’t and accelerate the adoption of good ideas across the sector.

For me, that openness remains one of TEC membership’s greatest strengths. Our role is not to pretend that every member faces exactly the same challenge or that there is a single answer. It is to bring people together, share knowledge and experience, and help members identify the solutions that fit their individual circumstances.

The challenge now is to turn that willingness to collaborate into faster, more coordinated action across cost, carbon and consumption reduction.

And perhaps that brings me back to the central thought I took away from the conference.

We cannot control the next geopolitical event. We cannot control every market shock or policy intervention. And we certainly cannot predict with confidence what the energy landscape will throw at us next.

But we can control the quality of our data, the way we bring people together, when and how we consume energy, the breadth and resilience of our commercial arrangements and the investments we choose to make.

 

In an increasingly unpredictable world, perhaps the route to greater resilience is not trying to predict what happens next. It is becoming much better at controlling the things we can.

Skip to toolbar